Even experienced developers get authentication wrong. Here’s what they keep missing and how to fix it before it becomes a breach.
Introduction: Authentication Is Not Just “Login + JWT”
Most developers think API authentication is simple:
User logs in → server issues JWT → client stores token → done.
That’s the story in every quick-start tutorial. But in the real world, things aren’t that clean.
Tokens leak. Sessions don’t expire. Refresh endpoints are abused.
And before you realize it, your “secure API” is quietly allowing anyone with the right token to impersonate users indefinitely.
Authentication isn’t about just verifying credentials; it’s about managing identity safely over time.
Here are the five most common mistakes developers make when handling API authentication and how to fix them the right way.
1. Storing Tokens in the Wrong Place
Let’s start with the classic.
Most developers do this after login:
localStorage.setItem("token", accessToken);
It works, it’s convenient, and it’s insecure.
Why It’s Dangerous
Anything stored in localStorage or sessionStorage can be accessed by JavaScript running on your page.
If your app ever suffers from XSS (Cross-Site Scripting), an attacker can simply run:
console.log(localStorage.getItem("token"));
Boom, your user’s session is gone.
The Correct Way
- Store short-lived access tokens in memory only (React context, Redux, or a variable).
- Store refresh tokens in HTTP-only cookies, which can’t be read by JavaScript.
- Use CSRF tokens to prevent cross-site attacks.
Example (Express):
res.cookie("refreshToken", token, {
httpOnly: true,
secure: true,
sameSite: "Strict",
});
This makes token theft via scripts nearly impossible.
2. Using Long-Lived Tokens
Developers often set JWTs to expire in days or even weeks because re-authentication feels “inconvenient.”
But long-lived tokens are like giving out permanent keys; once leaked, they never expire.
Real-World Risk
A token valid for 30 days gives attackers a huge window to exploit it. Even if you patch the vulnerability tomorrow, the stolen token still works.
The Fix
Adopt short-lived access tokens (10–30 minutes) and long-lived refresh tokens.
When the access token expires, issue a new one via the refresh token.
const accessToken = jwt.sign({ id: user.id }, JWT_SECRET, { expiresIn: "15m" });
const refreshToken = jwt.sign({ id: user.id }, JWT_SECRET, { expiresIn: "7d" });
Short expiration windows dramatically reduce the damage from token leaks.
3. Treating JWTs as “Stateless Forever”
JWTs are stateless, that’s their beauty and their curse.
Developers love that they don’t have to check a database on every request. But that also means you can’t revoke them easily.
Common Oversight
If a user logs out or a token leaks, there’s often no way to invalidate it until it expires.
Attackers with old tokens can continue making valid requests for hours or days.
The Right Way to Handle It
Implement token rotation and revocation.
- Track issued refresh tokens in your database.
- When a refresh token is used, mark it as “used” and generate new tokens.
- If an old refresh token reappears, block the session immediately.
Example:
if (refreshToken.used) {
throw new Error("Token reuse detected");
}
refreshToken.used = true;
await save(refreshToken);
This ensures that each token can be used only once, a key defense against replay attacks.
4. Ignoring Token Claims and Validation
A shocking number of APIs verify JWT signatures but ignore the claims inside them.
That’s like checking someone’s ID but not reading the name.
Common Mistake
const payload = jwt.verify(token, process.env.JWT_SECRET);
// OK ✅ but missing claim validation!
If you don’t verify the issuer (iss), audience (aud), or expiration (exp), Any valid token signed with the same secret can be reused, even from another service.
How to Fix It
Always verify the token context:
const payload = jwt.verify(token, process.env.JWT_SECRET, {
audience: "myapi.com",
issuer: "auth.myapi.com",
});
And double-check exp and nbf timestamps to ensure the token isn’t expired or not yet valid.
Pro Tip: Rotate JWT secrets periodically. A leaked signing key can compromise your entire system.
5. Forgetting About Revocation and Logout
One of the biggest myths in modern auth:
“JWTs don’t need logout just let them expire.”
That’s fine in theory, but in production, users log out, passwords change, and security incidents happen.
Without a proper revocation system, old tokens remain valid until expiry, and that’s dangerous.
The Solution
Maintain a revoked token store (a simple table or Redis cache) keyed by jti (JWT ID).
When a user logs out or resets their password:
- Add their tokens
jtito the revoked list. - Check this list during every authentication step.
Example:
if (revokedTokens.has(payload.jti)) {
return res.status(401).json({ error: "Token revoked" });
}
This tiny step prevents reusing stolen or expired tokens.
Bonus: Security Starts with How You Think
Authentication errors don’t usually come from ignorance; they come from convenience.
Developers cut corners to save time, assuming “it’s just internal,” “we’ll fix it later,” or “no one will find this.”
Attackers love those assumptions.
The real mindset shift is this:
- Don’t design for ideal users.
- Design for malicious ones.
- Make sure every assumption about trust is explicit, not implied.
That’s how mature APIs stay secure at scale.
Recap: The 5 Mistakes and Their Fixes
If you solve these five, your API authentication will already be more secure than 99% of web apps.
Conclusion: “It Works” Isn’t the Same as “It’s Secure”
Your authentication might be functional, users log in, tokens work, endpoints respond, but that doesn’t mean it’s safe.
Real security isn’t about encryption or frameworks. It’s about designing systems that stay trustworthy even when something leaks.
Every API you build carries an invisible promise: that user data is safe in your hands.
So take the time to do it right: short-lived tokens, proper validation, secure storage, and real logout handling.
Because once a token leaks, it’s too late to wish you had.
Call to Action
Which of these mistakes have you seen (or made) in your own projects?
Share your story or lesson in the comments; it might help another developer avoid the same trap.
And if you found this helpful, bookmark it for your next API review; your future self (and your security logs) will thank you.
Leave a Reply